407-917-4111

Rich Dealers Blog

The Cheapest Lead Is Not the Cheapest Car

November 2026 · Jimmy Vee & Travis Miller

Your agency calls with good news. Cost per lead is down.

Wonderful. How many cars did you sell from those leads?

If nobody can answer that, the celebration is a little premature.

You advertise to create business. A cheap inquiry that goes nowhere still costs money. A more expensive inquiry that helps produce a sale may be a much better buy.

The trouble starts when the report rewards the first number and nobody checks the second.

Watch what happens when you buy the cheaper leads.

Here’s an illustration, using made-up numbers.

Two channels each produce 100 leads. Channel A costs $12 per lead, or $1,200. Two buyers purchase. Advertising cost per sale: $600.

Channel B costs $24 per lead, or $2,400. Five buyers purchase. Advertising cost per sale: $480.

Which channel looks better on a lead-cost report?

Channel A. Which one costs less per sale? Channel B.

Move money toward the cheapest lead without checking the sales, and you can make the cost of selling a car go up. The spreadsheet congratulates you while you pay for the mistake.

Give the leads a process before you judge them.

We use the Fundamental Law of Lead Conversion as a working benchmark:

  • About 100 unique, valid leads.
  • About 85 connections.
  • About 42 appointments.
  • About 21 shows.
  • About five sales.

It’s a diagnostic model, not a promise that every batch behaves identically. It gives you a way to examine the steps between response and sale.

At $2,400 for those 100 leads, five sales means $480 in advertising per sale.

About $500 is the growth target we use with dealers, with room for market differences. The point is to understand the economics well enough to make a decision.

Then investigate the drop-offs. Are the inquiries valid? How quickly did the team respond? What happened on the calls? Did appointments show? What happened when they arrived?

You can’t diagnose all of that from cost per lead.

A number you can watch over years.

One member with stores on the Washington–Idaho line told us:

“Half my day was wasted on media I didn’t understand.”

From 2021 through 2025, those stores kept Google advertising cost per matched sale below $500 in every month on record.

In March 2025, Google matched 107 sales at about $174 each.

That’s a result connected to the business. A lead-cost improvement needs to earn the same connection.

Read the story.

Ask for matched sales and advertising cost per matched sale by channel. Compare Google with Meta, including Facebook and Instagram, using sales results alongside lead costs. Keep total store sales separate from sales matched to those leads.

Use cost per lead to understand the campaign. Use the sales and conversion process to decide whether the spending makes sense.

Our free Marketing Waste Report starts with where your budget goes and where the connection to sales needs a closer look.

Channel A and B are illustrative. The conversion sequence is a benchmark. Actual dealership results come from the linked case study. Advertising cost per matched sale excludes Rich Dealers fees.

Cheap leads have to prove they’re a good buy.