407-917-4111

Rich Dealers Blog

If Your Ads Lead With Price, You Trained the Buyer

November 2026 · Jimmy Vee & Travis Miller

Your customer has your price, two competing prices, and a question: “What can you do?”

Before you blame the customer, pull up the ad that brought them in.

Did it give them any reason to choose you besides the number?

If your whole pitch is that you’re cheaper, don’t act surprised when the buyer wants you cheaper still. You started that conversation.

It’s worth deciding whether you want to keep paying for it.

A dealer decided to ask for a different customer.

An independent dealer in Tallahassee spent years working on the customer mix he wanted to attract.

He explained the decision in March 2024:

“We have spent the last few years trying to attract that ‘little better customer’ and not constantly targeting the credit challenged customer.”

By August 2020, he had reported that 40% of the store’s customers had A or B credit, the highest share since 2012.

The point is the deliberate choice. He thought about who he wanted to reach and gave the advertising attention accordingly.

Read the story.

A different customer mix doesn’t happen because you complain about the customers you have. You have to examine what your message invites.

Price belongs in the conversation. It doesn’t have to be your entire identity.

A shopper searching for a particular truck needs information about that truck. Nobody is suggesting you hide the price.

But if the vehicle and the number are the only reasons you offer, you make yourself easy to compare with every store carrying something similar.

What does the buyer learn about your people? Your process? Your ability to help with a problem they haven’t solved?

Same Is Lame. In this case, sameness means you’re buying attention without giving the customer much reason to prefer your store.

That applies on Google and on Meta, including Facebook and Instagram. The message deserves as much consideration as the placement.

Give the buyer another reason to choose you.

At a May 2018 member meeting, we discussed a dealer who checked the credit bureaus of 15 customers responding to radio advertising. Fourteen showed no other dealership credit inquiry in that check.

That’s a useful glimpse of customers reaching the store before another dealer had run their credit. It doesn’t tell us every website they visited. It does give the dealer a different starting point from a customer arriving with three competing credit applications.

We call someone who wants to do business with you for a reason beyond low price a Fantastic Customer.

You help create that preference by understanding what the person wants to accomplish and explaining why your store can help.

The Tallahassee dealer reported a 116-delivery record month and said he was “having the time of my life” implementing ideas from us and other dealers.

That’s a more interesting goal than winning another race to the lowest advertised number.

Review your last few ads. Write down the reason each one gives a buyer to choose you. If every answer is price, start there.

The Tallahassee figures and quotes are dealer-reported case-study results. The credit-inquiry example comes from the May 2018 member meeting and concerns 15 radio respondents. Individual results vary.

Your message helps shape the conversation at the desk.