407-917-4111

Case study · Budget Car Sales · Radcliff and Muldraugh, Kentucky

From 35 Cars a Month to More Than 200

People around Fort Knox knew the store as “Tony Malito’s car lot.” Tony gave them plenty of reasons to remember.

Tony Malito in a red, white and blue stars-and-stripes blazer, giving two thumbs up, with his team behind him
Tony Malito Jr., Budget Car Sales

Ask a local about Budget Car Sales, and the name might not register.

Say Tony Malito, and you’re getting somewhere.

“People in area don’t really realize who Budget Car Sales is, they know Tony Malito’s car lot.”

Tony Malito Jr., May 2025

Tony has been on the radio every day since 2012. Santa Malito and Baby Malito are part of the mix.

There’s a real person in the advertising. Somebody the market can recognize.

When Tony joined Rich Dealers, he was selling about 35 cars a month. Before COVID, the stores were selling more than 200.

When the showroom closed, Tony kept selling.

Kentucky’s governor closed showrooms in March 2020.

Tony stayed on the air and sold at the curb.

“We’re open with a closed showroom.”

Tony Malito Jr., March 2020

By July, Google’s advertising cost per matched sale was about $199.

Years later, his store manager explained why having a steady flow of opportunities mattered:

“The reason why we were able to survive the recession, and even, like, COVID and all that, is because we had leads.”

Growth changes what you need to fix next.

In May 2021, Tony said:

“Leads is not my constraint right now. Inventory is the issue but our grosses have more than compensated for our volume.”

Later, the constraint was converting phone calls into appointments.

Tony identified that problem in October 2024. Rich Dealers began weekly call training the next month.

In 2026, Tony started sending each salesperson’s appointment rate to his managers every week.

By April, he reported that four people were consistently above 50% and said the work had made a difference.

That’s how you keep improving a store. Find what’s holding sales back, give it attention, and check whether it changes.

The name recognition kept producing opportunities.

In March 2025, a Google campaign running on Tony’s name alone produced matched sales at about $214 each.

In August 2026, Google matched 41 sales, the highest count since 2022.

Tony reported more volume than the stores had seen since COVID.

The advertising made Malito memorable. The work inside the store helped turn the response into business.

The 35 and 200+ monthly sales figures are reported by Tony’s stores and Rich Dealers. Matched sales are connected to Rich Dealers leads using the stores’ sold lists. Advertising cost per matched sale excludes Rich Dealers fees. These are individual dealership results. Outcomes depend on market, execution, and effort.

Before you buy more leads, find out what happens to the ones you already get.