407-917-4111

Case study · Frank Myers Auto Maxx · Winston-Salem, North Carolina

More Than 92% of the Google Leads Were New to the Store and Its Facebook Leads

Tracy Myers already had a strong Facebook operation. He wanted Google to bring additional buyers. Then he checked whether it did.

Tracy Myers, on the left, and another man in matching stars-and-stripes top hats and dark suits on the cover of Digital Dealer magazine, May/June 2022
Tracy Myers, left, on the cover of Digital Dealer, May/June 2022

If your current advertising works, the next question is pretty simple:

Will another channel bring you people you aren’t already reaching?

Tracy Myers wanted the answer.

The fourth-generation family dealer had run a strong Facebook operation at Frank Myers Auto Maxx for seven years. By his account, it produced about 100 sales a month at $133 per car sold.

His initial goal for Google was ten more cars a month.

In February 2026, he approved the new campaign:

“Let’s get started. I’m excited. I’ll put everything in y’all’s hands.”

Tracy Myers

Tracy checked the overlap himself.

Within two weeks of the March launch, Tracy compared the Google leads with dealership visitors and Facebook leads.

“More than 92% haven’t been to the dealership before or been a Facebook lead. That is excellent. ALL signs point to nothing but opportunity.”

Tracy Myers, April 2026

That answered the first question. Google was reaching people his existing operation hadn’t reached.

The campaign delivered more than 800 leads a month, with full-month lead costs between $5.42 and $6.90.

The new leads needed a different follow-up approach.

Tracy’s text team was already strong.

But Google buyers didn’t respond to texts as readily. So he hired his first outbound callers since COVID.

That’s an important part of the story.

A new channel can bring you different buyers. Your team has to pay attention to how those people respond.

With leads holding at about 800 a month, Google-matched sales increased from eight in May to 17 in August.

The ten-car goal was exceeded across the four reported months.

Across April, May, July, and August 2026, 47 sales matched back to Google leads.

That’s about 12 a month, at $421 in advertising spend per matched sale.

August produced 17 matched sales at about $293 each, the campaign’s best month so far.

Tracy started with a working Facebook operation, added Google to reach additional people, and adjusted the follow-up when those buyers behaved differently.

That’s how you give a new opportunity a fair chance to produce.

The 92% is Tracy Myers’s April 2026 cross-check. The 47 matched sales cover April, May, July, and August 2026. Advertising cost per matched sale excludes Rich Dealers fees. These are individual dealership results. Outcomes depend on market, execution, and effort.

Is another advertising channel bringing you additional buyers? Find out what your marketing dollars are doing.